Files
stackpilot/backend/tests/test_helper_containers.py
menzeljandClaude Opus 5 34458c702c
CI / check (push) Successful in 13m50s
CI / build-and-push (push) Successful in 2m11s
Mount NFS destinations with nolock so they need no nfs-common (0.66.2)
An NFSv3 mount with locking makes the kernel register its lock manager
with rpcbind on the Docker host itself. On a host without nfs-common the
mount fails with a bare "connection refused" that reads like the NAS is
unreachable, even though the NAS and its ports are fine.

Only StackPilot ever writes the backup files on an NFS destination, one
writer per file, so nothing needs locking. mount_options() now adds
nolock unless the options already choose (lock, nolock, local_lock=) or
ask for NFSv4, which locks in-protocol and needs no rpcbind. Existing
destinations get their volume recreated once with the new options.

The refused-mount hint now points at rpcbind/nfs-common on the Docker
host first, and "protocol not supported" explains the missing kernel
module (modprobe nfsv4). The form labels the option.

Co-Authored-By: Claude Opus 5 <noreply@anthropic.com>
2026-09-18 16:29:37 +02:00

264 lines
9.7 KiB
Python

"""Throwaway containers must not outlive their job.
docker-py's ``containers.run(remove=True)`` only removes a container after it
ran. A helper whose start failed — an NFS destination that refuses the mount —
stayed behind in "Created", holding the destination's volume. Every retry of
"Test" or of a scheduled backup added one (a user found 18), and because the
volume stayed in use, changing the destination's mount options never took
effect: the volume could not be recreated with them.
"""
from __future__ import annotations
import pytest
from docker_client import HELPER_LABEL, DockerError
class FakeContainer:
def __init__(self, client, image, command=None, volumes=None, labels=None, status="created"):
self.client, self.image, self.command = client, image, command
self.volumes, self.labels, self.status = volumes or {}, labels or {}, status
self.removed = False
def start(self):
if self.client.start_error:
raise DockerError("docker_api_error", self.client.start_error)
self.status = "exited"
def wait(self, timeout=None):
self.client.wait_timeouts.append(timeout)
return {"StatusCode": self.client.exit_code}
def logs(self, stdout=True, stderr=True):
return b"out" if stdout else b"boom"
def remove(self, force=False):
self.removed = True
self.client.all.remove(self)
class FakeClient:
def __init__(self, start_error=None, exit_code=0):
self.start_error, self.exit_code = start_error, exit_code
self.all: list[FakeContainer] = []
self.wait_timeouts: list = []
self.containers = self
self.volumes = FakeVolumes(self)
self.images = self
def create(self, image, command=None, volumes=None, labels=None):
c = FakeContainer(self, image, command, volumes, labels)
self.all.append(c)
return c
def get(self, image):
return object()
def list(self, all=False, filters=None):
filters = filters or {}
out = list(self.all)
if "label" in filters:
out = [c for c in out if filters["label"] in c.labels]
if "volume" in filters:
out = [c for c in out if filters["volume"] in c.volumes]
return out
class FakeVolume:
def __init__(self, client, name, options, labels):
self.client, self.name = client, name
self.attrs = {"Options": options, "Labels": labels}
def remove(self):
if any(self.name in c.volumes for c in self.client.all):
raise DockerError("docker_api_error", "volume is in use")
del self.client.volumes.items[self.name]
class FakeVolumes:
def __init__(self, client):
self.client = client
self.items: dict[str, FakeVolume] = {}
def get(self, name):
if name not in self.items:
raise DockerError("not_found", name)
return self.items[name]
def create(self, name, driver, driver_opts, labels):
self.items[name] = FakeVolume(self.client, name, driver_opts, labels)
return self.items[name]
def list(self, filters=None):
label = (filters or {}).get("label")
return [v for v in self.items.values() if not label or label in v.attrs["Labels"]]
def test_container_that_cannot_start_is_removed():
from docker_client import run_container
client = FakeClient(start_error="failed to mount local volume: connection refused")
with pytest.raises(DockerError, match="connection refused"):
run_container(client, "alpine", ["true"], volumes={"nfs": {"bind": "/nfs"}})
assert client.all == []
def test_failed_command_is_removed_and_reports_stderr():
from docker_client import run_container
client = FakeClient(exit_code=2)
with pytest.raises(DockerError) as info:
run_container(client, "alpine", ["false"])
assert info.value.error == "container_failed" and info.value.detail == "boom"
assert client.all == []
def test_successful_run_returns_stdout_and_is_labelled():
from docker_client import run_container
client = FakeClient()
seen = []
original = client.create
client.create = lambda *a, **k: seen.append(k["labels"]) or original(*a, **k)
assert run_container(client, "alpine", ["echo"], timeout=900) == b"out"
assert seen == [{HELPER_LABEL: "1"}] and client.all == []
assert client.wait_timeouts == [900]
def test_startup_removes_stopped_helpers_only():
from docker_client import remove_stale_helpers
client = FakeClient()
stale = client.create("alpine", labels={HELPER_LABEL: "1"})
busy = client.create("alpine", labels={HELPER_LABEL: "1"})
busy.status = "running"
foreign = client.create("nginx", labels={})
assert remove_stale_helpers(client) == 1
assert stale.removed and not busy.removed and not foreign.removed
def _nfs_dest(options="rw"):
from models.backup_destination import BackupDestination
return BackupDestination(id=1, name="nas", type="nfs", config="{}"), {
"server": "10.10.1.80", "path": "/mnt/user/Share", "options": options,
}
def test_changed_nfs_options_take_effect_despite_leftovers(monkeypatch):
from services import backup_destination_service as svc
client = FakeClient()
monkeypatch.setattr("docker_client.get_client", lambda: client)
dest, cfg = _nfs_dest("rw")
name = svc._nfs_volume(dest, cfg)
# 18 helpers left behind by failed mounts under the old version.
for _ in range(18):
client.create("alpine", volumes={name: {"bind": "/nfs"}})
dest, cfg = _nfs_dest("rw,nfsvers=4")
assert svc._nfs_volume(dest, cfg) == name
assert client.volumes.items[name].attrs["Options"]["o"] == "addr=10.10.1.80,rw,nfsvers=4"
assert client.all == []
def test_volume_held_by_a_running_container_is_a_clear_error(monkeypatch):
from services import backup_destination_service as svc
client = FakeClient()
monkeypatch.setattr("docker_client.get_client", lambda: client)
dest, cfg = _nfs_dest("rw")
name = svc._nfs_volume(dest, cfg)
client.create("alpine", volumes={name: {"bind": "/nfs"}}).status = "running"
dest, cfg = _nfs_dest("rw,nfsvers=4")
with pytest.raises(svc.DestinationError, match="still in use"):
svc._nfs_volume(dest, cfg)
def test_clear_nfs_leftovers_covers_every_destination():
from services import backup_destination_service as svc
client = FakeClient()
client.volumes.create("stackpilot-nfs-dest-1", "local", {}, {"stackpilot.nfs-destination": "1"})
client.volumes.create("stackpilot-nfs-dest-2", "local", {}, {"stackpilot.nfs-destination": "2"})
client.volumes.create("app_data", "local", {}, {})
client.create("alpine", volumes={"stackpilot-nfs-dest-1": {}})
client.create("alpine", volumes={"stackpilot-nfs-dest-2": {}})
keep = client.create("postgres", volumes={"app_data": {}})
assert svc.clear_nfs_leftovers(client) == 2
assert client.all == [keep]
def test_refused_mount_says_what_to_do(monkeypatch):
from services import backup_destination_service as svc
client = FakeClient(start_error=(
"error while mounting volume: failed to mount local volume: mount "
":/mnt/user/Share: data: addr=10.10.1.80: connection refused"
))
monkeypatch.setattr("docker_client.get_long_client", lambda: client)
monkeypatch.setattr("services.stack_assets_service.ensure_helper_image", lambda c: None)
with pytest.raises(svc.DestinationError) as info:
svc._nfs_run("stackpilot-nfs-dest-1", ["mkdir", "-p", "/nfs"])
assert "rpcbind" in str(info.value) and "2049" in str(info.value)
assert client.all == [] # and nothing is left behind
# --------------------------------------------------------------------------- #
# nolock: NFS destinations that work without nfs-common on the Docker host
# --------------------------------------------------------------------------- #
@pytest.mark.parametrize(
"options, expected",
[
(None, "rw,nolock"),
("", "rw,nolock"),
("rw", "rw,nolock"),
("rw,soft,", "rw,soft,nolock"),
("rw,nfsvers=3", "rw,nfsvers=3,nolock"),
("rw,lock", "rw,lock"), # asked for locking: respected
("rw,nolock", "rw,nolock"),
("rw,local_lock=all", "rw,local_lock=all"),
("rw,nfsvers=4", "rw,nfsvers=4"), # v4 locks in-protocol, no rpcbind
("rw,vers=4.1", "rw,vers=4.1"),
],
)
def test_nolock_is_added_for_nfs_v3_only(options, expected):
from services.backup_destination_service import mount_options
assert mount_options({"options": options}) == expected
def test_existing_destination_is_remounted_with_nolock(monkeypatch):
"""A destination saved with plain "rw" gets its volume recreated once."""
from services import backup_destination_service as svc
client = FakeClient()
monkeypatch.setattr("docker_client.get_client", lambda: client)
dest, cfg = _nfs_dest("rw")
name = f"{svc._NFS_VOLUME_PREFIX}{dest.id}"
# As 0.66.1 and earlier created it.
client.volumes.create(name, "local", {
"type": "nfs", "o": "addr=10.10.1.80,rw", "device": ":/mnt/user/Share",
}, {"stackpilot.nfs-destination": "1"})
svc._nfs_volume(dest, cfg)
assert client.volumes.items[name].attrs["Options"]["o"] == "addr=10.10.1.80,rw,nolock"
def test_refused_mount_points_at_rpcbind_on_the_docker_host(monkeypatch):
from services import backup_destination_service as svc
client = FakeClient(start_error="failed to mount local volume: connection refused")
monkeypatch.setattr("docker_client.get_long_client", lambda: client)
monkeypatch.setattr("services.stack_assets_service.ensure_helper_image", lambda c: None)
with pytest.raises(svc.DestinationError) as info:
svc._nfs_run("stackpilot-nfs-dest-1", ["true"])
assert "nfs-common" in str(info.value)